In this episode of the EdGate Powers Podcast, Rich Portelance speaks with Jane Swift, CEO of Education at Work, about the growing importance of work-based learning and the skills students need to transition successfully into the workforce. Drawing on her experience in public service and education, Swift discusses the widening gap between what students gain through traditional education and what employers expect from new graduates.
The conversation explores the challenges facing early-career job seekers, including the increasing difficulty of securing paid internships and the expectation that entry-level applicants already have relevant work experience. Swift explains how Education at Work helps address this gap by connecting students with paid employment opportunities that build technical experience, confidence, and workplace skills. These opportunities can come from jobs that are not traditionally considered prestigious internships but still provide valuable experience.
Swift also emphasizes the importance of durable skills such as communication, problem-solving, adaptability, and resilience. As generative AI changes entry-level work and employer expectations, students need opportunities to develop these skills through real experiences. She argues that education must do more to identify how durable skills are developed, define what success looks like, and connect those competencies with academic learning and career preparation.
The discussion concludes with the importance of stronger collaboration among schools, employers, and higher education institutions. Swift highlights career exploration in middle school, paid work experiences in high school, and closer connections between college programs and employer needs. She also discusses the importance of strong reading and writing skills and using AI to support thinking rather than replace it. Ultimately, she encourages students to gain real work experience and learn to recognize the transferable skills they develop along the way.
- Paid work experience can play an important role in helping students secure their first jobs after graduation. Students need opportunities to develop relevant skills and demonstrate that they can apply what they have learned in a professional setting.
- Work-based learning does not have to begin with prestigious internships to be valuable. Everyday jobs can help students build technical knowledge, communication, problem-solving, and other skills that transfer across industries.
- Durable skills are increasingly important as AI changes the nature of entry-level work and employer expectations. Education and workforce partners need to better define, develop, and assess these skills through meaningful experiences.
- Schools, employers, and colleges each have a role in preparing students for employment. Stronger partnerships can connect early career exploration, paid work experiences, and academic programs with real workforce needs.
- AI can help students organize and communicate their ideas, but it should not replace their own thinking. Students also need strong reading and writing abilities, personalized applications, and concrete examples that demonstrate their skills and experience.
- The role of paid internships and work-based learning in career readiness
- Barriers facing students entering the early-career job market
- Education at Work's role as an intermediary between students and employers
- Developing durable skills through real workplace experiences
- Transferable skills and their relevance across different industries
- AI's impact on entry-level employment and student preparation
- Career exploration, employer partnerships, and education pathways
- Resume development, the STAR method, and communicating workplace skills
|
Host, EdGate Powers Webinar Series |
Chief Executive Officer, Education at Work |
Making Paid Work Experience More Accessible to Students
Swift explains that students increasingly face expectations to have relevant work experience before they can secure their first professional jobs, even when those opportunities are difficult to access. Education at Work helps address this challenge by connecting students with paid roles that provide practical experience, technical skills, and exposure to workplace expectations. By treating a wider range of jobs as opportunities for development, students can build experience that helps them pursue future career opportunities.
Notable Insight
“The single greatest predictor of whether or not you will get a good job coming out of college is whether or not you had a paid internship.”
Key Questions Explored
- Why are paid internships becoming so important for students entering the workforce?
- How can students gain meaningful experience when traditional internship opportunities are difficult to access?
- How can intermediary organizations help connect employers with student workers?
Developing Durable Skills Through Real-World Experiences
Swift describes how employers are looking for more than technical credentials, placing increasing importance on communication, problem-solving, adaptability, and other durable skills. She argues that students need opportunities to develop these capabilities through work, where they can experience challenges, learn from mistakes, and recognize how their skills apply in different settings. She also points to the need for clearer standards, rubrics, and assessments that help define what these skills look like across different ages and industries.
Notable Insight
“Skills are much more transferable than, you know, how you cut a tomato.”
Key Questions Explored
- Which durable skills are employers looking for in today's changing workforce?
- How can work-based learning help students develop and recognize transferable skills?
- How can education systems define and assess durable skills across different industries?
Connecting Schools, Employers, and Career Preparation
Swift emphasizes that preparing students for employment requires collaboration rather than expecting schools or employers to solve workforce challenges independently. She describes a progression that includes career exploration in middle school, paid work experiences in high school, and stronger connections between college programs and employer needs. She also highlights the importance of helping students communicate their experiences through strong writing, personalized applications, and concrete examples of how they have demonstrated workplace skills.
Notable Insight
“Let's not have college trying to fix the private sector and the private sector trying to fix college, but let's have both of them work to their strengths.”
Key Questions Explored
- How can employers provide meaningful career exploration and work opportunities before students graduate?
- What should collaboration between higher education and employers look like?
- How can students communicate their workplace experience and durable skills to prospective employers?
What This Means for Education Leaders
Education leaders have an opportunity to make work-based learning a more intentional part of the student experience. Career exploration can begin before high school, while paid experiences and practical workplace responsibilities can help older students develop skills and understand professional expectations. Districts can also look for ways to connect classroom instruction with local employers, workforce agencies, and community organizations that can expand access to these opportunities.
The conversation also highlights the need to address durable skills alongside academic knowledge and technical competencies. Communication, problem-solving, adaptability, and resilience develop through experience, but students need help recognizing and articulating what they have learned. Schools can consider how projects, internships, and other work-based experiences create opportunities for students to demonstrate these capabilities and connect them to future career pathways.
Finally, stronger partnerships with employers and higher education institutions can help schools respond to changing workforce needs without expecting any one institution to anticipate every shift. Employers can contribute career exploration and practical experience, while colleges and schools continue developing the academic foundations students need. As AI changes how people work and communicate, education leaders should also emphasize strong reading, writing, and critical-thinking skills, ensuring that technology supports rather than replaces students' ability to think independently.
Q: Why is paid work experience important for students preparing to enter the workforce?
A: Paid work experience gives students opportunities to develop technical abilities, workplace habits, and durable skills before graduation. Swift explains that having a paid internship is a particularly important predictor of whether a student will secure a good job after college.
Q: How can students gain career experience without securing a traditional internship?
A: Students can build valuable experience through everyday paid jobs, including roles that may not be directly connected to their intended careers. Swift describes how experiences such as tax preparation can help students develop transferable skills and gain professional experience that supports future employment opportunities.
Q: What is Education at Work, and how does it support work-based learning?
A: Education at Work is a national nonprofit that connects students with paid work opportunities through partnerships with employers, schools, higher education institutions, and workforce organizations. It acts as an intermediary, helping reduce the administrative and operational barriers that can prevent employers from hiring students while providing students with practical experience and skill development.
Q: What are durable skills, and why do employers value them?
A: Durable skills include capabilities such as communication, problem-solving, adaptability, and resilience that can be applied across different jobs and industries. Swift explains that these skills are increasingly important as AI changes entry-level employment and employers need workers who can handle more complex responsibilities.
Q: How can schools help students develop transferable skills?
A: Schools can connect academic learning with real-world experiences through internships, projects, career exploration, and work-based learning opportunities. These experiences help students recognize that skills developed in one setting, such as customer service or teamwork, can apply to entirely different careers.
“Be a barista during school so that you don't have to be a barista after you graduate.”
The following transcript has been edited for readability. Timestamps have been removed and minor transcription errors corrected. Speaker comments and context have been preserved.
Opening Remarks
Rich Portelance
Good afternoon, everyone. This is Richard Portelance. I'm your host for the EdGate Powers Podcast. With me today is Jane Swift from Education at Work. I'm going to let Jane introduce herself here in a second. We're super excited to have her along. As everyone knows, this is the third year that we've been doing the State of Standards in the fourth quarter of the year. This year, our theme is “CTE Rising: How Career and Technical Skills Are Driving Standards in Education.” And so, it's very appropriate that we're having a conversation with Jane today because she's at the “connector point” of where employers are and where education and skills meet.
Just a reminder to everyone that on December 10, we will be having an executive forum. Jane will be there, along with Daylene Long from Catapult X, and Rita Ferrandino from Arc Capital Development. So, we are super excited. We're going to be streaming live on LinkedIn and YouTube, so please join us. There is a link below so you can sign up right now. Make sure you're there. It's going to be a fantastic conversation with three really fabulous guests. So, without further ado, Jane, could you introduce yourself?
Jane Swift
Sure. So, it might be– maybe I'll work backwards and tell you about Education at Work, which actually helps my story and brings it full circle. So, Education at Work is a national nonprofit. We are dedicated to helping students gain work experience, and through that work experience, we believe they gain the critical skills that, when you partner them with education, will help them to get a good first job. And so, we partner with cities, states, workforce agencies, higher education institutions, forward-thinking companies, and all of those folks together we connect so that those paid work-based learning opportunities and experiences are available to students in both high school and college. And again, that is what enables a smooth transition to a good first job.
I always joke that my mom, who was a teacher until she retired many decades ago and is still alive, used to say that she started her teaching career in kindergarten, and that– she stayed at home for a long period of time as a stay-at-home mom, and then as her children grew up, she sort of grew up in the education profession once she went back to teaching after we were all out of the house. And by the time she retired–she never quite got to the college level, Rich–but by the time she retired, she was teaching freshman religion, Old Testament, in the catholic school system. So, number one, you should know I do not mess with my mom because she taught in the catholic school system under the Old Testament.
But, I started my career in public service, but I started my career in public service on a mission to improve public education. I grew up in a blue-collar, industrial city– in fact I just talked about my mom–she still lives in the house that my parents bought when my mom was pregnant for me and my brother, John, was an infant. We call ourselves Irish twins. I actually became quite famous, you may remember, when I was pregnant with twins when I was serving as governor. But, I found my way into politics because I was a good student in my blue-collar, industrial, small city, and went off to Trinity College all excited–I was going to be a sports reporter–I was going to, you know, conquer the world! And I got there, and I realized a couple of things: I realized that my family was not wealthy, and I figured out what a BMW was–I had never heard of one before. This was a long time ago, I’m about to go to my 40th college reunion! And I also figured out that I didn't write well, and I wasn't well prepared for college–and that was a shock to me. And I am catholic; my dad is the oldest of six, and I have siblings, and also 14 younger cousins, and we're all very close, even to this day. And I was determined, as only a 23-year-old can be, that I was going to fix the education system in some way so that my younger siblings and, mostly, my adored younger cousins wouldn't be at the same disadvantage I was when I showed up at Trinity College. And hopefully someday, I'd make enough money so that I would wear the right clothes when I showed up at these fancy places, and places like the Main Line that I also didn't know existed until I went to Trinity College.
So fast forward, my dad had actually always worked as a volunteer in politics, and there was a funny story that my mom told him that she would marry him if he never ran for office, but he could volunteer. I joke that I was the best-behaved of the four children, and so I got to go with him. But I was really lucky to be able to win my first election, serve in the Massachusetts Senate where we wrote an education reform bill, then to become lieutenant governor and governor where I implemented that bill. And when I left office, I told my dad who–we’re doing this the morning after a historic election–this is one of the days when I really miss my dad. But I told my dad that I wanted to leave office, but I still wanted to work in education, I wanted to work with people I liked, I wanted to have fun, I wanted to make a difference, and I wanted to make more money because you don't make a lot of money in public service. And he told me that was a very selfish way to look at the world, and not very many people had the opportunity to do that. And for the last over 20 years–23 to be exact, because I can date it based on how old my twins were when I left office and how old they are now–I've been really fortunate, Rich. I've worked exclusively in education–I've had almost every job there is. I've been a board member, an advisor, a CEO, a head of business development; I speak, I've served on boards, I've advised wonderful companies like Sally Ride Science.
But about five or six years ago, as my own kids were making their way through college, I realized that Jane Swift's story, right? Go to a great liberal arts college, get Pell Grants, work in the cafeteria scraping dishes, but I got a good job out of college, and hard work, you know, a little bit of luck, and I’ve had a really, really different life from my parents. My kids have had a really different life from their mother–they showed up in all of the right clothes in their first year of college. And what I realized is that story wasn't playing out for not them, but for kids who showed up on the college campuses that they were at who are a lot more like Jane was 30 years earlier. And, if you know anybody or ever meet anybody from North Adams, which you probably will, because we always say, “Everything always comes back to North Adams, Massachusetts,” you can't see it, but if you grew up there, we all have a chip on our shoulder, and we carry it around with us for the rest of our lives. And that chip on my shoulder really angered me that in this economy today, kids who are doing everything right, working hard, going to college, are not getting good jobs out of college. And so, when Education at Work came knocking at my door and said, "Do you want to help fix this problem?" I said, "Heck yes." And it has been a ride. My colleagues and I, who I'm fortunate to have a great team, would tell you–this last week was my third-year anniversary at Education at Work–and I think the challenge has changed just about every six months.
Discussion
Rich Portelance
Well, there's a lot to unpack there, Jane, and that was a great opening. Thank you so much. I love that you’re taking us back to the point where, you know, your Catholic education informed where you went in life. And, you know, I have a– my wife was dyslexic, and one of the nuns at her Catholic school told her to stop reading because it “hurt her ears.” That was their, you know, their way of handling dyslexia, and she is a teacher today for some of the same reasons. You know, when you look at that background and that passion and how that's driven you throughout your career, do you feel blessed that you've had that ability and that blessing to help in education, or do you feel like that was predestined? How does that make you feel?
Jane Swift
To those to whom much is given, much is expected. I am at a certain age where I'd love to get a little more sleep. I used to be able to sleep anywhere, but… You know, I served on the National Assessment Governing Board (NAGB) for a while, and what an honor that was. But, you know, educational attainment right now is headed in the wrong direction. There are– so, in the sector that I'm in right now, trying to help more students get paid work experience, whether that's high school internships and paid opportunities in the summer, or college students getting paid internships, did you know it's harder to get a paid, high-quality internship in the summer right now than it is to get into Harvard? Those are the chances that you will get one of those opportunities. And yet, the single greatest predictor of whether or not you will get a good job coming out of college is whether or not you had a paid internship. It is one of those circular issues that keeps me up at night. I read every day on LinkedIn– like– and you probably saw the New York Times article the other day about students talking about this, about how difficult and frustrating it is. What I started to see with my daughters were all of these job postings that were advertising themselves as opportunities for new graduates, but they wanted students to have one year or two years of experience with very explicit experience with certain technologies or tools that required you to have had one of these paid internships.
And I'll tell you the one that finally almost, like, made my head explode. Two of my daughters today work in the sports industry. It's actually an industry that's been, well, until the baseball strike, maybe, or lockout, but has been fairly resistant to economic battering by AI. So, a lot of kids are attracted to it, and I love sports, but it’s a hard industry to break into; it’s very competitive, and especially so for young women. And so, my daughter, Elizabeth, is a baseball nut, and really was trying to break into the MLB, and she got really deep into a couple of interviews with a couple of teams. And in one of them, when she was like one of three finalists and didn't quite make it, someone actually said to her, "Well, you know what you could do this spring? You could just go to Florida for spring training and buy a TrackMan,” which is that thing that you actually get the speed of the pitches on, “because you don't have experience with that yet. And just go down and pick, like, you like the Red Sox, go down to the Red Sox spring training in Fort Myers, and just stand there and start just like tracking the speed of the pitches and recording it. Get some experience because you really need experience with that technology, Elizabeth. That'll really help you!”
And I thought to myself, this is a kid who just graduated with a degree in math from UMass Amherst, worked for three years in security for the Red Sox, has been in the industry, has done a bunch of other things, but I was like, “He has no idea who her mother is, what she's done. In what world does a kid who's just graduated from college have the money to go spend the spring without a job in Florida, buy a $2,000 piece of equipment, and pay to go into every spring training game so that they can, on a whim, start tracking pitches?!” I was like… And even she, right, who frankly, if I lost my mind at some point in my life and she was a spoiled kid, we probably could have done it. But I was like, “Are they serious, Elizabeth?” Like, maybe if somebody said, “You can have this job for a lot of money with a defined ladder of success if you do this,” maybe I would do that. I’d still think it was terribly unfair, but like… and… it… but there's an equivalent of that, Rich, in almost every job posting you see. And so, how are we supposed to get kids there? We think that what we do at Education at Work, and if we can start getting kids experience, getting them job-ready, that is one of the solutions. But it's hard, because we still have to convince employers to take on these kids.
Rich Portelance
So that paints a really vivid picture of what's happening in the landscape and the unfair treatment of saying, you know, “You can spend money on housing, and being able to get into the stadium, and then buy the equipment, and then track all the pitches, and, well, you may have an opportunity.” That’s a ridiculous scenario. Let's set that up now with Education at Work, because I don't think the audience knows exactly what you do, and I think it's super relevant, and then we can talk about how that applies to CTE (career and technical education) standards, and what we're going to try to do to change the game here.
Jane Swift
Yeah. So, we're an intermediary, which, if you understand the work-based learning industry, it's a well-understood term. But if you don't, basically, we employ the students, and what we like to say is–and maybe a parent would understand this–we take out all the friction between the employer and the new employee, who, in this case, would be a student–so whether that's at the high school level or it is at the college level. And so, part– there are two reasons that folks are not hiring students. One is that our economy has been hugely disrupted by all kinds of technologies, and that is making the early-career market really volatile–chief among them is generative AI. But the second is that a lot of repetitive tasks are being done by AI, or they don't require any sort of college-level skills, and students are like, “I'm, you know, not doing that,” or “That's not going to prepare me to be a, you know, finance guru or a private equity investor.” And so, the opportunities to develop employability skills are less.
And so, then what employers see is when they hire these first-time employees, they both don't have the higher level of technical skills that now they need to hire those entry-level employees for, because they've got technology doing the basic stuff. But also, they don't have the kind of experience that you would have gotten if you started on the bottom rung, and you learned to show up on time, and how to communicate when you didn't understand something, how to ask for time off appropriately, when it's appropriate to ask for time off, what you do if you're on your way to work and you get a flat tire and you're going to be five minutes late, how to ask what you should wear to your first day of work. All of those things that… and I will tell you that they are also the kinds of things that I thought about a lot as a parent, right, like, all the sort of incremental advantages. I always say that one of the things that we do at Education at Work as an intermediary are the things that you do if you don't have a mother like me. If you are a student, right, who is trying to break into a job or an industry that your parents have no experience with, and there are no longer all these training programs that you spend your first six months in as a new hire, who tells you all of these things? Who tells you that when the boss's boss is coming into your office, you should dress a little nicer that day? My girls know that, right? My daughter told me this is “cultural capital.” Rich, you probably knew that. I wouldn't have known that when I showed up from North Adams, Massachusetts at Trinity College, or my first job at G. Fox & Co. before I ran for office, but I was in an executive management training program–they taught us those things. There was going to be a store visit. Everybody shined everything and stayed up all night and matched all the things, but we don't have as many of those jobs anymore. And so what we now do, right, is we fill jobs at scale or smaller jobs, and we fill real needs in the workforce.
But what we do for students is we take jobs that they may not think of as high-prestige internships. So, one of them is tax preparation, which… and we layer on other skill-building, other skill development, and we help them to understand at either the high school or the college level how the job you're doing may not be the job you want forever. It may not even be in the company that you're eventually going to get an offer. So, this isn't like the elite Goldman Sachs summer where at the end the, you know, golden ring is the six-figure offer. This is “You're going to have experience.”
So, I'll give you a great story–it's a true one–it just happened. We hired a student at ASU (Arizona State University) who did tax preparation for us all last year. We kept a couple of students on board who helped us with another contract we had where they were helping students in New Mexico, our high school program, fill out their W2s, get their I-9s all set up, they did some speaking to these students about making a good first impression, general employability stuff. Janeth has stayed with us. She's been actually helping us sort out some of our HR stuff, doing an onboarding book for the next wave of students who will track tax preparation this year. Janeth has never done a Big Four accounting internship, but she is an accounting major. Now she has got a job when she graduates with Deloitte. So, we are proving that we can take other roles, teach you the skills, so Deloitte… you know, now listen, if Deloitte wants to come hire us and let us hire a hundred kids not in their fancy internship, we will help them fill gaps in their employment too, but we take jobs that are not the like, fancy just internships, but real jobs that you can't fill, and we help awesome students who need the opportunity to build skills, confidence, and often technical credentials so that they're ready with the two years of experience and the skills that go along with it to land the openings that exist in our workforce.
Rich Portelance
Well, it's a great mission, and I love to hear what you're doing. It's so needed in society. Whether it's for some of these entry-level white-collar jobs or for blue-collar jobs, it's about getting kids the skills.
Jane Swift
By the way, I'll tell you a story about Lorenzo who did a plumbing internship with New Mexico that the state paid for, and there are different skills that Lorenzo needed, right? Like, I grew up in a plumbing family, and so, you know, their goal with Lorenzo was, like, make sure you look people in the eye, make sure you shake their hand, the importance of being on time, how do you– Like, so, there are different skills that everybody needs. And again, now, I don't know all of their names, right, because we had thousands of students who worked for us at the high school and college level last year. But as you can tell, learning many of their names and stories is, you asked me, if I felt it was a blessing–well, clearly it animates me.
Rich Portelance
Yes, it does. It lights you right up, and that's a wonderful thing when you, you know, kind of find your calling. And I'm curious because we talked about some of the critical thinking and some of those skills you mentioned. Are those the skills that the employers are asking for you to help the students develop so that they're technically “job-ready?”
Jane Swift
Yes. And, you know, like, we call them durable skills. I think that's sort of a phrase that's widely used. Some people call them human skills, soft skills, whatever you call them. I think the challenge right now is that there is wide recognition that employers are looking for those skills–maybe more today than they have in the past, and perhaps even at an equal level or maybe even more than certain technical credentials. Ten years ago when I was working for Sally Ride Science on her board, encouraging kids to be a computer science major was a really good strategy. Right now, computer science grads are among some of the hardest to place, and they need to have an ability to show a growth mindset, and they need to have other, you know, durable skills. The challenge is when we tell a student to go major in STEM and to be a computer science grad, and even if, you know, we go from Ruby on Rails to natural programming, to C++–I don't know if you can tell, but I'm not a computer person–but whatever it is, right? Or learn AI… We are very specific about what it is that we need them to do and what success looks like.
The problem–and I think this is a problem for employers–and frankly it's an opportunity for us as intermediaries. It's also a challenge for us in designing programs, particularly at scale. The problem is, I know you know as a parent, as an employer, what a high level of skills, problem-solving, and communication looks like, what we haven't gotten to yet; and where I think we are heading, we're still in the early days of how we meet the needs of the workforce. So, as I think about it, I was lucky enough to be in the wave and in a decision-making body when the workforce demanded of us that we increase the academic skills of our children in order to meet the needs of the workforce. We needed more STEM graduates; we needed students who had a higher level of English and math. And so, the response was that we needed to set standards for high school graduation–we needed to align those in a knowledge economy for what was required.
In this generative-AI-volatile economy, we now need to pair those academic skills with these durable skills. But what we haven't gotten to yet is how those durable skills developed in and through work. How do we– what are the standards? What's the rubric? What are the assessments? Until we know what success looks like at different ages for different industries, perhaps, and I was talking to one of the other folks who's going to be on our panel, she's like, "Do you think problem-solving skills that you develop in work-based learning look the same in the science industry as they would look if you had become a sports reporter?" I don't know. Right?
Rich Portelance
Right.
Jane Swift
I don't know if anybody knows.
Rich Portelance
And then that's what we have to try to find out. And how do we take some of those ideas and bake them into the education standards earlier on so that they're in line with what we're teaching kids so that it's not lost in translation? I mean, that's… right?
Jane Swift
And what we do in the classroom. So, in New Mexico, Albuquerque, actually, public schools are doing some great stuff in embedding work-based learning, pathways, and career exploration into the school year. We're starting to have discussions with them about… the state makes a huge investment in the summer internship program, so how do we connect not just the funding mechanisms–so kids who are doing this work during the school year access these opportunities during the summer–but how do you actually start to create pathways? So, we had one of the culinary teachers who asked us if she could use funding from the state program to extend her culinary program through the summer. And we had to be extremely flexible, maybe a little bit breaking rules, but that's where the former– my former title, I sort of take some liberties sometimes, but it was for the right reasons, right? And so, we allowed her to sort of build a program that allowed students to do things more intensively and develop different skills. We actually have a video; I don't know if it's on our website, but I should bring it when we do our panel–awesome experience.
Now, here, like, is a mind, like, we are getting ready to do our tax program for this coming year. A student came to our job fair at the University of New Mexico in Albuquerque. He's like, "Hey, I worked for you this summer! I was in the culinary program!" Now, why a student who was in a culinary program in Albuquerque Public Schools now wants to do tax preparation? It only makes sense if you're a parent, right? There's probably, like, listen, both have a customer service piece, right? There probably are skills, and that's one of the things we need to teach our students, right? Skills are much more transferable than, you know, how you cut a tomato.
Rich Portelance
That's right. You know, when you're talking about critical thinking or interpersonal communications, these are things you can take with you. And do you see that there's a difference, or… where's the gap between what colleges are doing today and how they're preparing kids, and what the employers are expecting? Because you talked about the two-to-three years of experience, but there's got to be something else there that the colleges aren't doing, or there's a gap between there. Do you…?
Jane Swift
So, I, you know, I'm not an apologist for any institution. I actually talk about the “triangle of paralysis,” and I have issues with higher ed right now. First of all, they are squandering a lot of their buying power and their own ability to create more of these paid work-based learning opportunities. First of all, they do a lot of call center work–they do a lot of repetitive jobs that could be done by students. I know because we've responded to RFPs (requests for proposal) that colleges and universities have put on the street, and when we respond, they're like, "Oh, it never occurred to us to use students to do this work." And then they disqualify us because, you know, when you're doing an RFP, you know, square peg, square hole. But… so, I have that issue with colleges and universities.
I started off by saying to you that I've been in this job for three years, and I think I've been through six revolutions of what the early career hiring market is looking for. That might be a slight exaggeration, but not much. Part of the reason I always say to folks, here's one way to think about it: go on LinkedIn, or whatever your sort of listserv of choice is on news about early career hiring, what's going on in the young adult job market, and read it for 48 to 72 hours, and come back and tell me what the consensus is, as to whether or not we are hiring more college graduates because of AI, fewer college graduates because of AI, the same amount, does it depend on industry? And the truth is, you will not be able to tell me, because on any given day, you will see a legitimate survey–legitimate research–that says all of the above. And the truth is that the industry is seeing the same thing we're seeing, which is a lot of volatility. Some are introducing human-centered AI, and it is not as simple as it seems. Others are trying to replace jobs with AI, and they haven't done this before, and it ends up causing problems in places they didn't expect. Some people are finding that they have huge vulnerabilities because of existing technology because of AI, and that's creating jobs in places they never expected, right? Bank of America, I think, just hired, like, hundreds of people to close some security gaps. So, you know, we weren't going to need any computer programmers, but now we all of a sudden need a whole bunch of security programmers, right? So, that's all to say that the volatility creates such enormous variability in what employers need, and I can barely keep up with it, and it's all I do and all I think about every day to expect higher education to be pivoting their entire curriculum and to expect professors– whose job is not my job. That's why there are intermediaries, right? Their job is not to run a company and to know what goes into it, or what Apple or Walmart is going to need in their workforce. And if those big companies or small companies can barely figure out– if Bank of America didn't know six months ago that they had a huge security vulnerability, how was some professor at ASU or UMass Amherst supposed to know and prepare the graduates who will graduate this year for that? That's not fair. Now, they could be preparing students for an economy that is changing that quickly and thinking more strategically, and some are, but not enough. So that's what I would say is, like, thinking they can figure out how to fill these gaps in this rapidly evolving economy isn't fair. Asking them to think about how they need to evolve their model to be in this really volatile, rapidly changing economy, because that's what their students are going to have to deal with. But frankly, a lot of them are having to start to deal with that as well.
Rich Portelance
So, is it fair to say, Jane, that it would be wise to look at the K-8 paradigm, and start to embed those skills and figure out how do we start to teach those durable skills so that kids are more adaptable?
Jane Swift
I think adaptability, resilience, problem-solving… but I also think– so, my theory of action–somebody taught me that word, so now I sound… I have great glasses, and I sound like I know what I'm talking about. But I think what we need to do is that we need to accept that you're going to need both academic skills and durable skills through experience. And the one exposure to what you're good at, exposure to what you're not good at. An ability to build passion, right? So, you asked me also earlier, and I've gotten in a big fight at South by Southwest (SXSW) a few years ago on this, but I'm sticking to my guns. You asked me if I get joy or enjoy what I do and if it's been a blessing. And obviously I've demonstrated, right? I enjoy what I do. Not that I don't get tired, and not that at times I'm not ready to flip out, but I think teaching kids that being really engaged, and curious, and passionate about what you do, and finding meaning in work is really, really important, because that's what, for me, finding meaning, finding purpose is what builds resilience. It is what helps you to do the hard stuff, right? And there's going to be a need for a lot of adaptability, a lot of resilience, and to tackle a lot of hard stuff. That's about the only clarity I can find for young people in this economy.
Rich Portelance
And you know, in terms of a skill, you talked earlier about, you know, you got to college, and you realized you couldn't write. Do you think that having that capacity and that capability to craft good prose today is more essential than it was even 30 or 40 years ago when you and I were coming out of school?
Jane Swift
So, I actually think it is. I don't know if you saw one of my earlier podcasts, but I think the ability to read and write well is extraordinarily important, and this is why. I had a huge privilege for almost 10 years to teach at Williams College–so, some of the smartest kids in the country. I used to tease them because I went to Trinity and if you know NESCAC (New England Small College Athletic Conference), I'd say, “Here's the thing: you’re smarter than me–I had more fun in college. That is just like table stakes.” But if you cannot write well, you are not thinking well. And if you are not widely read, you are not able to process a variety of different ideas; you are not able to think deeply, and absorb knowledge, and deal with this volatility. So, you know, the greatest gift that my parents gave me and their children was a love of learning that started with a love of reading.
Rich Portelance
I, you know, it's funny. I didn't do well in school. I had a hearing deficit, and it didn't come out till later on. And then when I realized, you know, you realize what you lost. But I had the privilege of being able to work at a secondary school, Canterbury School, for about four years.
Jane Swift
My brother went there!
Rich Portelance
Who did?
Jane Swift
Yeah, my brother!
Rich Portelance
Oh, really?
Jane Swift
Yeah. He's a good hockey player. He went there on a scholarship.
Rich Portelance
Oh, there you go. It had a great hockey program! And my boss at the time was the former head of the English department, and he was, you know, he was teaching all the really smart kids when I went to school, but now, all of a sudden, he's my boss and he's editing everything I wrote, and it was technical documents, as well as he started having me write for The Pallium, which is their literary magazine.
Jane Swift
Yeah, I know, I've seen the magazine come through! They still mail it, yeah.
Rich Portelance
That was the greatest four years of my life in terms of, like, a master's degree from someone who really understood how to write. And from that day forward, I felt like I had gained such an advantage over my, you know, brethren going out into the field because I understood how to write and craft context so much better. And yeah, I would agree with you that that strength, and today in the world of prompting, you know, we talk about, you know, how people are going to adapt in the age of AI, and, you know, early on when you're in eighth grade, you don't have enough knowledge to understand how to prompt well. You can learn skills when you're in college, and now, you can apply thinking and how do you do this well. And so there might be some things that we can start to connect within the standards, within the curriculum, to kind of build that paradigm and build that strength so that kids are more successful when they walk out the door. How do you feel about that? Does that resonate?
Jane Swift
Well, and I will tell you, like, I– so, there are times in your younger life, right, where writing a paper, writing it all is such a burden, right? And I find in my life today that writing is therapy; it's joy. I write a lot. My staff probably wishes that I would write a less lengthy and verbose email sometimes. But I… my husband died almost five years ago, and I started to write a blog post that, shockingly, other people began to read. But I found that the ability to process my thoughts and the therapeutic nature of writing. And so, now with AI, which I still use–I used to have a note on my phone that had a Grammarly app on it. Using AI, whether it's Grammarly or Gemini, or something else to process your thoughts... But what I found with the prompts and AI, I can pull things I've written at all different times, and like, “Wait I remember I wrote that,” or “I wrote that somewhere else.” It's like my secretary, right? It's not thinking for me–it's grabbing things that I've said at different times. And so, I agree with you. I think, used wisely, right, to help take different pieces and writing.
But I do think–I think this on a number of things–we need more research because there's some scary research about overuse making us dumber. And so, how we teach students to use AI, not just to make sure that the things that we're seeing are correct and truthful, but how it improves our ability to think and to process information. Because if we're using it to not think, right, as opposed to sharpening our thinking, I think that's a danger. And I'm not sure we understand yet the different ways that works.
Rich Portelance
So, I'm curious, because of the work you're doing at this intersection between school, students, and work, are you seeing some change in how students need to prepare their resumes? And how is that viewed by employers? Because I'm hearing a lot of challenges there, and if you're going to display skills and you're going to display experience, it has to come through some vessel. We've used the resume, but is that outdated, or what's happening there?
Jane Swift
It's really hard, and I've seen it as an employer, right? I just did a thing for Business Insider. I mean, the one thing I would say–and I'm not an expert–but for a long time, you had to, like, embed the keywords and make sure the screeners like it. Now everybody knows that, and everybody can do it, and employers are getting just inundated with these AI-generated cover letters. And so, one of the things that I have said to folks is, even with our little old, small nonprofit, we will post a position, and we will get nearly identical résumés and cover letters, and they're not from the same person, and they don't have the same experience.
And so, what I've said to students is, of course, as a time-saver, use AI because now you're sort of in this mad race, right? Like, everybody else is going to send out a hundred resumes and cover letters, so you can't, like, only send out two or three. But if you're going to use AI, use it to tailor what you are sending, and then please, for the love of God, edit it and personalize it. But now, I'm sure you know this, but like, you have these systems that will tell you which part of your cover letter looks like it's generated by AI–so AI is detecting itself.
Rich Portelance
I was going to say, AI is detecting AI. It's really a vicious cycle. When I was talking to Don Fraser, Jr.–there's a podcast available if you're listening to this–Don Fraser is on, and we talk about students not recognizing that they've been able to develop skills, and he gave the example of a student who worked as a barista. And so, he starts to question them, saying, “Oh, you know, what did you do when you were there? Who did– you know, you were talking to people, and, you know, how did you handle a certain circumstance when maybe a drink order was misplaced or something went wrong?” You know, these are executive functioning skills that are being developed on the fly in a very real situation. How do you… When you work with students at Education at Work, are you helping them to extrapolate those skills and understand that they've actually got more than they probably think they do?
Jane Swift
So, that's one of the keys, right? Because not every job is glamorous. And so– and what employers will tell us is, yes, they want you to be able to have communication skills or to have, you know, problem-solving skills, but just saying, "Oh, I have problem-solving skills," and again, in this Business Insider interview that I just had, I talked about how you need to show, not tell. And so, one of the things that I tell our students, that I tell my children, that I said in this interview is that I suggest–I don’t think I have one right here–but keep a little notebook if you can, and if it's legal at work, and I teach my students something that I frankly didn't know about.
One of my daughters, one of the ones who's also working in sports when she was trying to break into the very competitive industry of professional and college football–actually, a woman who was, at that point, the highest-ranking woman in the NFL, connected her with another young woman who had just busted through that, and this woman said to her, “Lauren, you need to know the STAR method of interviewing because you’ve got great experience.” Lauren had worked for three years for the Northwestern football team. She's like, "But you have to be able to communicate your strengths through the STAR method." And so, for anybody who's listening and doesn't know, the STAR method is Situation, Task, Action, and Result. And so, last winter, when some of our students were struggling with parts of their role as tax preparers, I would say to them, I had this saying, which I'm at an age I can repeat myself, Rich. I would say, "Make your worst day your best day." But one of the hardest questions to answer in any interview is, "Tell me about a time you made a mistake or you messed up." They won't say messed up, but when you made a mistake, or you had a challenge, and how you responded to that. And one of the best answers to that question is to have a real scenario and to use it to show either problem-solving or resilience, but the best way to do it is to show it aligned to one of the durable skills that the employer has asked for in the job posting. And so, what I say to students is that if something really bad happens at work, like you told somebody the wrong answer, or you accidentally hung up on someone in the middle of a call and you couldn't get it back, and that was going to bring down your… You know, SQS score, whatever it was, take two, write down the situation, set the scene, provide the context–this is what happened. Then, write down what I was supposed to be doing. What was my responsibility? What was my task? What was the goal that I was supposed to be addressing? And then, talk about the action. What did I do? Right? If I accidentally disconnected from somebody because I was… you know, on my screen there was this or there was that, right, how did I identify what had caused me to make that mistake and make sure that it wasn't going to happen again, and then later, do the result, right?
And so, whether it's that you did that–if you're interviewing for a job that calls for research skills, maybe you have the– and by the way, I'm a politician, so I always tell my kids, like, you can sort of morph the result, but if you have a real situation, a real task, and a real action, you can make the result sound like, “I didn't make that mistake again,” because if they want research skills, “I went home that night and did some research about the highest performers,” right? If it's resilience, “I wanted to quit, but I went to my boss and said, ‘How many people have made this mistake before? And can you give me an example of a high performer who has made that mistake and what they did?’” Right? So now you're showing that you not only have resilience, but you know how to go and find–so anyway, but I always say to my students to remember STAR, right? And also, if you have big wins or you do, like– but write down those situations.
And the other thing that I say to them is that you're going to make a mistake. Nobody is perfect. And if in the moment when that happens, you know, “Okay, this sucks. I'm so embarrassed, but this is going to be my winning interview question or answer on that job someday.” It might be when you're 40 years old for a job I really want. I said, “Even if the answer is, ‘Let me tell you, when I was an intern at Education at Work when I was 20 years old, I got a phone call, and I thought it was my boss, and I went to Sephora and bought $800 of gift cards because I really thought she was texting me as–’” This is a real story, by the way, and let me tell you what happened, right? Make it your… knowing that someday, that story is going to be your best day, get up, keep going.
Rich Portelance
I love that story. And I'm curious, and this is, you know, is it possible for us to teach that kind of resiliency and grit while maintaining an A through F paradigm in our educational system? Because if we're saying failure is bad when kids are young, but then we say later on failure is an opportunity, how do we get that to connect?
Jane Swift
There was a time in the early 2000s when there was a little bit of a fad around teaching resilience and grit. I actually was just looking at some books in my bookcase, and there's one about teaching grit and resilience. Again, right, cultural capital. And also, there's a little bit of this in Jonathan Haidt’s, I think, lessons about The Anxious Generation. I think… can we do it in school? I don't know. But we can definitely do it as parents. And that may be why teaching it in these work-based situations, right? Where… so… maybe yes, but I think we need to figure it out as parents, right, like it's the hardest thing. I just had a call from one of my CEO moms that I love, and it had nothing to do with work; it had to do with middle school girls, and boy, parenting middle school girls is not for the faint of heart, and it's usually not yours; it's all the other ones, right? It's really… parenting is the hardest job you'll ever have.
Rich Portelance
I love that answer, Jane, because I'm a firm believer that, you know, all this stuff starts at home and, you know, sometimes we have to do some self-evaluation of how much we do for our kids and how much we let them, you know, experience things, so that they can have failure and resiliency and, you know, bounce back on their own. But that's a big conversation…
Jane Swift
Probably for a different panel.
Rich Portelance
Yes. So, if employers could help to redesign education before kids graduate, what are they going to change? What are you seeing that they would say, “Hey, you need to do this and this differently?”
Jane Swift
Actually, they can right now, right? I think more employers need to be thoughtful about how can they help work– so, back when I was… 30 years ago, 35 years ago in the Senate, there was the big movement to adopt a school. I forget exactly what it was called, but, right, we were doing, you know, school business partnerships, and a lot of it was just around, like, helping provide books, this or that. I think maybe we need something like that again where… but it's got to be real, right? Like, how are you going to start providing these real opportunities within your organization where, in middle school, you're helping to do career exploration?
So, there's lots of great products and edtech tools to do online career exploration, but do you know why I thought I wanted to be a sports reporter? Because– I don't even remember if it was– I think it was probably early high school, but it could have been eighth grade–the local newspaper had an opportunity where you got to go down there; I think it was every Thursday night for three or four weeks, and you got to see how the whole thing ran. And I remember the printing press and seeing how they edited the headlines, and I was just fascinated by the whole thing. And, you know, in the middle school years, because of child labor laws, frankly, those are the kinds of things we need, right? Career exploration. And then when you get to high school, those paid experiences where you're doing real work and pairing that with some employability and skill building, and then in college helping to sort of say, like– rather than employers saying, “How do we fix college?” I think they have to be more, “How do we pair, you know, some opportunities for students to get real-world experience and meet our workforce gaps with the programs that exist in college?” Right? Let's not have college trying to fix the private sector and the private sector trying to fix college, but let's have both of them work to their strengths, and figure out how we work together in a really volatile, fast-changing economy where we all want this generation to have opportunity and to do well. Because if they don't, who's going to pay for our Social Security?
Rich Portelance
Yeah, good.
Jane Swift
As much as I love my job, at some point, I just want to like… you know, I don't know.
Rich Portelance
A sip of Mai Tai and some–
Jane Swift
Probably not. That's probably not my thing. But I am about to become a grandmother, so there’s probably fun to be had there.
Closing Thoughts
Rich Portelance
There you go. We're running out of time. Jane. I've really appreciated the conversation. And just to remind everyone, click the link below. You're going to hear more from Jane Swift on December 10th, along with Rita Ferrandino and Daylene Long, and myself, as we talk about CTE Rising and how these career and technical education skills are driving standards in education. Jane, I guess the last question I have for you is for the students who don't have the pleasure of having Education at Work embedded in their school, you know, what do you tell them? How do they move forward so that they can have some of the success that your students are having?
Jane Swift
Get a job, and get a real job. I think there's a fallacy, and I forget who you said was the person who said, like, “You can be a barista.” And what I would say is, be a barista during school so that you don't have to be a barista after you graduate.
Rich Portelance
Well, Jane, thank you so much. And I would agree 100%. I know my kids worked their way through college, and it made all the difference.
Jane Swift
Mine too.
Rich Portelance
And yeah, whether you're sweeping floors or you're pouring coffee, it all makes a difference. All right, Jane, thank you so much for today.
Jane Swift
Thank you.